top of page

Azerbaijan Has Yet To Ensure Armenians’ Safe Return to Artsakh Three Years After UN Court Order, Ombudsman Says

4 hours ago
3 min read
Azerbaijan Has Yet To Ensure Armenians’ Safe Return to Artsakh Three Years After UN Court Order, Ombudsman Says

Three years after the United Nations’ highest court ordered Azerbaijan to ensure the safe return of ethnic Armenians to their indigenous homeland, Artsakh’s cultural heritage ombudsman says the ruling remains unfulfilled and is calling for stronger international action.


Hovik Avanesov, who also serves as an honorary board member of the UNESCO Armenia NGO, criticized Azerbaijan and the international community in a statement marking the third anniversary of the International Court of Justice’s November 17, 2023, order.


The ruling followed Azerbaijan’s September 2023 military offensive in Artsakh, which forced more than 120,000 ethnic Armenians to flee to Armenia. The operation ended decades of Armenian self-rule in the region and brought it under full Azerbaijani control.


The court ordered Azerbaijan to ensure that Armenians who left Artsakh after September 19, 2023, and wished to return could do so safely, without obstruction and without delay. It also required Baku to protect those who remained or returned and preserve records relating to residents’ identity and private property.

Avanesov accused Azerbaijan of failing to meet those obligations, arguing that displaced Armenians still lack the security guarantees necessary to return to their homes.


He also pointed to an earlier ICJ order issued on February 22, 2023, requiring Azerbaijan to ensure unimpeded movement along the Lachin Corridor, the only road connecting Artsakh to Armenia at the time.


According to Avanesov, the failure to enforce the court’s decisions has exposed serious weaknesses in the international legal system.


The ICJ’s provisional measures are legally binding, but the court has no enforcement body of its own. Under Article 94 of the U.N. Charter, a party may bring a dispute over compliance with a court judgment before the U.N. Security Council, which can consider measures to secure its implementation.


Avanesov argued that international institutions have failed to use their political and legal influence effectively, leaving displaced Armenians without a clear path home.


He also raised concerns about Armenian churches, monasteries, cemeteries and historical monuments now under Azerbaijani control. He warned that the loss or alteration of these sites would further weaken the connection between displaced families and the communities they left behind.


Many former residents also remain unable to access their homes, land and other property. Avanesov called for international documentation of property claims and independent monitoring of Armenian cultural heritage, including the use of satellite imagery.


He said housing assistance, employment programs and other support provided to displaced families in Armenia are necessary but should not be treated as substitutes for their right to return.


His statement also called for the restoration of Armenian statehood in Artsakh, insisting that displaced Armenians should return only under Armenian jurisdiction and without any Azerbaijani military, police or administrative presence.


Those demands go beyond the ICJ’s November 2023 order, which addressed the protection of ethnic Armenians’ rights but did not require a change in sovereignty over Artsakh.

Azerbaijan Has Yet To Ensure Armenians’ Safe Return to Artsakh Three Years After UN Court Order, Ombudsman Says

Azerbaijan maintains that the region is part of its internationally recognized territory and has said ethnic Armenians may return under Azerbaijani law.


Avanesov called on governments and international organizations to monitor compliance with the ICJ’s orders, investigate alleged rights violations, protect Armenian cultural sites and establish enforceable security guarantees for displaced residents.


He also urged international negotiators not to leave the rights of Artsakh Armenians out of discussions on peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan.


His appeal comes as the two countries pursue normalization after decades of conflict. While diplomatic efforts have focused on establishing lasting peace and expanding regional cooperation, the future of the Armenians who fled Artsakh remains unresolved.


Avanesov warned that allowing their displacement to become a permanent reality without addressing their rights would set a troubling precedent for international law.


He argued that a lasting peace cannot be achieved simply through agreements between governments while displaced people remain unable to return to their homes.


For the thousands of Armenians who left Artsakh in 2023, the court’s ruling has yet to produce a safe and practical way home.


—

Support independent reporting from the region by subscribing to The Armenian Report. Our team is funded solely by readers like you.

Comments


MC#3 Banner 160x600 Ad Text (1).png
SING_Desktop_160x600_edited.jpg
bottom of page